Callaway Ai Smoke Max D vs Ping G430 SFT
Both the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D and Ping G430 SFT target similar golfers, but they take different approaches to performance. The Callaway Ai Smoke Max D from Callaway debuted in 2024, while Ping's Ping G430 SFT launched in 2024. We put both through our scoring system to see which one delivers more where it counts.
Score Comparison
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Forgiveness
The Callaway Ai Smoke Max D edges the Ping G430 SFT 9.5 to 9.4 in forgiveness, but the 0.1-point gap is virtually identical in practice. You won't feel a real-world difference between these two here. Callaway Ai Smoke Max D's 9,300 MOI provides solid stability.
Distance
Both the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D and Ping G430 SFT score 8.4/10 for distance — a dead heat. Neither has a meaningful edge here, so this category won't be the deciding factor. Key tech like Ai Smart Face drives the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D's speed numbers.
Feel & Sound
The Ping G430 SFT edges the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D 8.2 to 8 in feel & sound, but the 0.2-point gap is virtually identical in practice. You won't feel a real-world difference between these two here. The Ping G430 SFT's 460cc head produces a confident, full-bodied sound.
Adjustability
A negligible difference in adjustability: the Ping G430 SFT scores 7.8/10 vs 7.4/10 for the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D. The 0.4-point gap is slim enough that other factors should guide your decision. The Ping G430 SFT offers Trajectory Tuning 2.0 hosel (8 positions) for fine-tuning.
Value
The Ping G430 SFT holds a modest edge in value at 7.8/10 vs the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D's 7/10. A 0.8-point advantage that's slight but could matter if value ranks high on your priority list. At $549, the Ping G430 SFT is priced in line with flagship competitors.
Specifications
| Spec | Callaway Ai Smoke Max D | Ping G430 SFT |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $599 | $549 |
| Year | 2024 | 2024 |
| Head Size | 460cc | 460cc |
| Lofts | 9°, 10.5°, 12° | 10.5°, 12° |
| Adjustable | Yes | Yes |
| MOI | 9300 | 9100 |
| Key Tech | Ai Smart Face, Forged Carbon Composite, Triaxial Carbon Crown | Carbonfly Wrap, Spinsistency Face Technology, Straight Flight Technology (Heel CG) |
Which Should You Buy?
If you want maximum forgiveness
Go with the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D. Its 9.5/10 forgiveness score means more consistent results on off-center strikes compared to the Ping G430 SFT's 9.4/10.
If you're on a budget
The Ping G430 SFT at $549 scores 7.8/10 for value — better than the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D's 7/10 at $599.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better: Callaway Ai Smoke Max D or Ping G430 SFT?
The Ping G430 SFT scores higher overall at 8.4/10 vs 8.2/10. It wins on feel and sound, adjustability, value. The Callaway Ai Smoke Max D is better for forgiveness. The best choice depends on your priorities and handicap level.
Is the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D more forgiving than the Ping G430 SFT?
The Callaway Ai Smoke Max D is more forgiving, scoring 9.5/10 compared to 9.4/10 for the Ping G430 SFT. It offers excellent stability on mishits.
Which is better value: Callaway Ai Smoke Max D or Ping G430 SFT?
The Ping G430 SFT ($549) scores 7.8/10 for value vs 7/10 for the Callaway Ai Smoke Max D ($599). It costs less and delivers more bang for the buck.